My name is Manny, and I’ve been a picky eater for 33 years.
[“Hiiii Mannyyyyy,” they reply, at Picky Eaters Anonymous]
I’m not the kind of picky eater that’s going to derail an entire dinner somewhere, but I’ve still proved to be an obstacle when going out to eat. Why? Because I don’t like seafood, and Devan and Noah do. So if we’re at some sceney, hyped-up spot in Manhattan getting share-plates, they’ve had to sacrifice what they would normally order just so that we can have an evenly-shared meal.
But I’m a man of sympathy. I feel bad that Devan and Noah can’t get their pungent, fishy little bug plates that slime about in my mouth and make me gag… so it’s time for a change.
(Amazon, Apple, Spotify, and more, YouTube)
In collaboration with
, Noah, Devan and I set out to see how feasible it is to cure picky eating. We spoke to Dr. Nancy Zucker, a professor of psychiatry at Duke University, who helped us come up with an experiment to get me on the right track. I have an open mind… but I also have my doubts.Here’s some things discussed in the episode:
First, the famous Roasted Salmon Glazed With Brown Sugar and Mustard recipe from the New York Times.
And here’s the absolutely ridiculous “pickle phobia” clip from Maury:
If you’re new here after hearing us on the Search Engine feed, here’s a quick NST starter pack to catch you up.
And in case you missed it, here’s our first appearance on Search Engine from last January: Why are there so many chicken bones on the street? Part 1 and Part 2.
Let us know how you feel about picky eaters in the comments below (are YOU a picky eater?), and if you like what you’ve heard, please give us a five-star rating wherever you listen to podcasts, and throw us a follow on Instagram, X fka Twitter, and/or TikTok.
Have an argument you want us to weigh in on? Shoot us an email at mannynoahdevan@gmail.com.
We’ll be back on Tuesday with a new episode.
I think its crazy and says more about everyone but Manny that you felt it necessary to make him feel social pressure just for not liking fish. Why does everyone have to like the same things? Would you do the same thing to someone who didn't like steak or pork or hotdogs? Just let people like what they like. It's not such a big deal.
As a reformed picky eater, I know the answer is yes!!! But I'll listen anyway 🤪 I wish I had figured it out sooner than age 20 and would love to know what a specialist has to say about it!